div id="slide">

How Are Elders Nominated?

Nominating Committees

  • What's wrong with the Nominating Committee?
    • The most serious practical deficiency of most nominating committees is that the primary criteria for placement on the nominating committee is demographic data, not spiritual maturity or biblical knowledge. 
      • It is often objected that demographic representation and spiritual maturity need not be mutually exclusive attributes of a nominating committee.  This is a formally true proposition. 
      • But the reality of most nominating committees is that few of the people around the table understand the qualifications for eldership, know the questions to ask in order to discern their presence or absence, or have the courage to nominate someone who meets the biblical requirements but may not be outwardly successful in other popular but peripheral areas.
    • The most serious biblical deficiency of the nominating committee concept is that nominating future leaders is a function of spiritual oversight - a responsibility that belongs to the current elders themselves.  Sheep don't choose their shepherds.
      • The result of error here is often that a successful businessman is nominated and appointed as an elder or deacon, yet with serious sin beneath the surface that biblically disqualifies him from serving.
    /div>