How Are Elders Nominated?

Is there a more biblical way?

  • Fifthly, recommend the candidate to the congregation as a nominee for eldership.  Let this nomination rest with the congregation for a period of time (e.g., two months), during which time members intending to vote "no" can share their concerns with the elders and the elders can, if necessary, withdraw the nomination based on new information. 
  • Sixthly, if no concerns are raised, achieve a 75% majority affirmation of the call from the congregation at the next business meeting.  This supermajority is necessary because it is important that the congregation have confidence in the new elder, and that the elder be assured of that confidence by the congregational vote.  Otherwise mutual mistrust ensues.
  • Finally, it is wise to allow elders to serve a three year term, to be reaffirmed by the congregation for another three years, then to give them a one year break, after which the other current elders could re-nominate them if they are still qualified.  This system provides healthy accountability for elders that a lifetime eldership system seems to lack.